Historic Castletown landmark approved for sale after Tynwald debate
A significant piece of Isle of Man heritage is heading to the open market. Tynwald has approved plans for Manx National Heritage to sell the historic Old Police Station in Castletown, ending years of public ownership and sparking passionate debate among lawmakers about how best to protect the island's architectural treasures.
Designed by renowned architect Baillie Scott, the Old Police Station is recognised for its considerable historic and architectural importance. The registered building has been owned by the Manx Museum and National Trust since 2018, when it was purchased to preserve it for future generations. Now, after private development plans stalled, the decision has been made to put it up for sale on the open market.
The motion, moved by Sarah Maltby MHK (Douglas South), generated considerable discussion in parliament on 22 April 2026. While supporters like Gary Clueit MLC called the move a pragmatic and necessary step for the charity, others voiced serious concerns about adequate protection once the building enters private ownership.
Key worries centred on whether existing legislation would be sufficient to ensure proper maintenance. Juan Watterson MHK, who originally brought the matter to Tynwald in 2018, expressed doubts about safeguards for a privately-owned historic property. Jason Moorhouse MHK (Arbory, Castletown and Malew) also raised concerns, alongside Tim Glover MHK, who questioned why funding pressures had forced the charity to this point.
Despite the reservations, the motion passed with overwhelming support. Only three members voted against the proposal, while all others—along with all Legislative Council members—backed the sale. Those in favour acknowledged that private owners will need better government support to maintain historic buildings, with calls for the grant system to be reconsidered to help protect Isle of Man's architectural heritage.
Source: Read full article on ManxRadio